|
Buy-Sell Agreements
By Paul K. Batt
"It's just not fair. I know the business is worth much
more than what I'm getting from the Buy-Sell agreement,"
explained the widow who just lost her husband. "I know,"
stated her deceased husband's business partner. "The
problem is, the buy-sell was drafted over 10 years ago, and
it hasn't been updated since then. In order to give you your
fair share of what this company is worth I would have to sell
the business, and then I would loose everything I worked so
hard for." "I'm not trying to be difficult,"
the widow replied, "But I have a mortgage and three kids.
I think I'm going to have to talk to an attorney."
Unfortunately this story is not as uncommon as you may think.
The Need for a Buy-Sell Agreement
According to a survey of beneficiaries of business owners,
only 21 percent of business owners had a formal plan to transfer
their share of the business at their death or disability.
Of the business owners that did have a plan in place, many
have not updated their plan in years.
Not having a plan in place for contingencies such as death
and disability creates a number of problems. Without a formal,
updated buy-sell agreement:
Surviving partners, shareholders, or family members may
be forced to sell or dissolve the business
The remaining business owners may have to decide how they
will compensate the decedent's family for his or her ownership
interest
The decedent's estate cannot be guaranteed it will receive
a fair price for the business interest
As a business owner you are typically focused on the day-to-day
operations of your company such as quarterly earnings, distribution
conflicts and getting that bid in - not the consequences
of a premature death or disability. But the short and long-term
consequences of losing an owner should not, and cannot,
be overlooked.
What is a Buy-Sell Agreement?
A buy-sell agreement is a legally binding contract that
requires the sale and purchase of ownership interests in
the event of the death, disability, or retirement of a partner
or shareholder. It is a separate legal document that ensures
that any ownership transition will occur as planned.
Usually these agreements are among co-owners, or between
owners and the company itself. It is also possible that
individuals who are not currently owners (such as a key
employee or family members) may be a party to the agreement.
Outlining a Buy-Sell Agreement
There are two key elements in developing a buy-sell agreement.
The first is ensuring that the company is valued properly
and the second is deciding how the transaction is to be
funded.
Business Valuation
Valuation not only assures that the business is transferred
at a fair price but also helps in establishing a value for
estate tax purposes. Determining the value of your company
is not a simple process and a professional appraiser or
your CPA should initially do this.
Updating the value of your company on a regular basis is
also very important. This can be done by a simple agreement
among shareholders at your annual meeting, or there may
be a formula in place that determines the new value each
year.
The Funding of a Buy-Sell Agreement
The second key element of a properly structured buy-sell
plan is the funding mechanism.
A buy-sell that is funded provides that the funds will be
available when they are needed to pay for the decedent's
business interest. There are a variety of ways that a buy-sell
plan can be funded, including installment payments, a sinking
fund, a loan, and life and disability insurance. Each technique
has its advantages and disadvantages. An unfunded buy-sell
plan could create complications and delays, adding to the
uncertainty that already surrounds the death or disability
of a business owner.
Types of Buy-Sell Agreements
There are many types of buy-sell agreements including the
entity purchase plan, cross-purchase, trusteed cross-purchase,
wait and see approach, and if you have no partners and are
the only shareholder, the key-person or one-way buy-sell
plan. You should discuss with an attorney which type of
buy-sell agreement would be appropriate for your particular
situation.
Whether you are a small two or three person operation, or
a shareholder or partner in a large corporation, having
a properly structured buy-sell agreement is critical for
the survival of your company. The loss of an owner can create
a void in both management and operation and hence creates
a significant challenge to business continuation. A properly
designed & funded buy-sell agreement can help solve
this problem and can help ensure that the business &
the careers that depend on it will continue.
Paul K. Batt, CFS, CLU, ChFC,
is director - Financial & Retirement Services of Minard-Ames
Insurance Group in Phoenix and Tucson. He can be reached
at
602-273-1625.
|